Table 4: Shear and Mode II Fracture Toughness Test Methods
|
Test Method |
Thick Adherend |
Torsion Butt Joint |
Napkin Ring |
ENF |
|
Mechanical Properties Obtained |
Shear strength/modulus |
Shear strength/modulus |
Shear strength |
Mode II fracture energies |
|
Material Quantity Requirements/Specimen |
Low |
Low |
Low |
Low |
|
Typical Specimen Dimensions (mm) |
Length 110 Width 5 Adherend thickness 26 Overlap length 5 |
Diameter 15–25 Adherend thickness 12–15 |
Length 356 Width 25 Adherend thickness 6 |
|
|
Materials Suitable for Testing |
1- 6 |
1—6 |
1—6 |
1 and 6 |
|
Cost of Specimen Fabrication/Preparation |
Low-moderate |
Low-moderate |
Moderate-high |
Low |
|
Cost of Testing/Specimen |
Low |
Low-moderate |
Low-moderate |
Low-moderate |
|
Specimen Fabrication Equipment Requirements |
Surface preparation Bonding = bonding jig |
Surface preparation Bonding + bonding jig |
Surface preparation Bonding + bonding jig |
Surface preparation Bonding + Bonding jig |
|
Specimen Instrumentation Requirements |
Extensometers (2 off) |
Rotary extensometer |
Rotary extensometer |
Travelling microscope or video camera |
|
Test Equipment and Fixture Requirements |
Self-stressed |
Universal test machine + loading fixture |
Torsion test machine + loading fixture |
Universal test machine + flexure fixture |
|
Fatigue performance |
Not suitable |
Suitable |
Suitable |
Suitable |
|
Creep Performance |
Possibly |
Suitable |
Unsuitable |
Unsuitable |
|
Environmental suitability |
Suitable |
Suitable |
Suitable |
Suitable |
|
Data Reduction |
Straightforward |
Straightforward |
Straightforward |
Straightforward |
|
Accuracy (Estimated) |
To be determined |
To be determined |
To be determined |
Large uncertainty (30%) |
|
Standard Test Methods Available |
ISO 11003 ASTM D 3165 |
None |
ASTM E 229 |
None |
1 = metal-metal; 2 = metal-plastic; 3 = metal-composite; 4 = plastic-plastic; 5 = plastic-composite; 6 = composite-composite.